Evangelical leaders join criticism of Chevrolet's sponsorship of Come Together & Worship Tour
Two weeks ago, when Weblog covered Chevrolet's sponsoring of the Come Together and Worship tour with Michael W. Smith, Third Day, and Max Lucado, the critics were Jewish watchdog groups like the Anti-Defamation League and the American Jewish Committee. Publishers Weekly's Phyllis Tickle was a critic, too, but the main voice was the AJC's James Rudin.
But the Anti-Defamation League, American Jewish Committee, and Tickle were all responding to reporters' questions. They didn't take the initiative as critics. Now, however, some voices are proactively criticizing the Chevrolet sponsorship. And — surprise — they're evangelical leaders.
Perhaps most critical is Christian singer Steve Camp. "Undiscerning believers think it a profound ministry strategy to join forces with unregenerate people in forwarding the gospel," he wrote in a six-page open letter to the contemporary Christian music community. "Unwittingly, they harness Jesus Christ, the Worthy One, with Belial or Satan, the worthless one, in an unholy alliance—the very essence of being unequally yoked. … Allowing the world to sponsor and partner in the work of the ministry is foreign to any biblical writer. I don't know of any other singular event that has allowed the world to conduct its business or trade where the worship of the Lord is to be given and the gospel proclaimed. … Has the church traded the great theme of 'Holy, Holy, Holy' and adopted as their new song of praise, 'Like a rock'?"
But Camp isn't just critical of the sponsorship. He's upset with the tour itself; specifically, that it's charging an admission fee. "We have now actually digressed to charging people money to worship the Lord," he complains.
Surprised by Camp's reaction? You don't know Camp. The Encyclopedia of Contemporary Christian Music notes that he has always been an activist and a critic of the Christian music world, but in recent years has stepped up his criticisms. On Reformation Day (Oct. 31), 1998, he famously (infamously?) issued 107 Theses for reforming the industry. "Most biblical scholars and Christian theologians would regard Camp's arguments … as certainly sectarian and probably unscriptural," wrote encyclopedia author Mark Allan Powell, professor of New Testament at Trinity Lutheran Seminary.
But Camp isn't alone. Not by a long shot. The Evangelical Environmental Network (EEN) has put together an open letter to automobile executives, signed by more than "100 heads of denominational and senior religious leaders," and will even run television, radio, and print ads in Detroit criticizing the company and tour.
"Through this gospel tour, Chevrolet is promoting certain vehicles that get very low gas mileage and produce significant pollution, harming human health and the rest of God's creation. Is this loving your neighbor?" says EEN executive director Jim Ball in a press release. "The real problem is the cars, not the concert. If Chevrolet wants to promote family values, then they should start by creating a healthier environment for our children to play in. … We're asking the artists and audiences to take a good look at what's happening here, and to ask, 'What Would Jesus Drive?'"
So the EEN has launched WhatWouldJesusDrive.org. The organization's Call to Action statement is there, but so far there's no list of those denominational and religious leaders. For that, apparently, we have to wait until the ads are revealed November 20. Nor does the site include the EEN's letter to the band Third Day, which says, "We think it would be a shame if many of your fans were influenced by this tour to buy such Chevrolet vehicles."
Meanwhile, others are defending the tour. "Corporations have the right to target specific groups that will use their product," says an editorial in The Oklahoman. "We haven't heard the same kind of outrage at 'corporate America' for courting other customers categorized into specific groups. For example, Bridgestone/Firestone has focused its products in markets for homosexuals and lesbians, African-Americans, Asians and Hispanics. … Thankfully, Chevrolet didn't cave in to unreasonable pressure and pull out."
And USA Today quotes pastor Max Lucado, who is speaking on the tour. "Corporate America, not necessarily Chevrolet, has gotten behind events that were violent or more controversial in nature. For them to get behind something nourishing in nature is refreshing. … But, the line that I won't cross, and I haven't been asked to cross: At no time has any advertiser told us what to say or to sing at the event."
Ossuary owner breaks his silence
After being called an idiot for packing a 2,000-year-old bone box that may be the most exciting New Testament archaeological find ever in cardboard and bubble wrap, and after being accused of trying to smuggle the priceless treasure out of Israel, and after being accused of dealing in looted artifacts, ossuary owner Oded Golan has come out of hiding to defend himself. The front-page story in Toronto's Globe and Mail has several notes that contradict what has been previously reported:
- After its exhibition at the Royal Ontario Museum, the ossuary will return to Israel, but not to Golan's home. (Museum authorities wonder if it will be able to withstand another transport after the damage it received going from Israel to Canada.)
- "From an archeological point of view this is not so important a finding," Golan says. "[But] from a religious and emotional point of view it is a completely different issue." (Many archaeologists would disagree on that point.)
- When buying the James ossuary from an Arab antiques dealer in the 1970s, Golan says he chose it over other artifacts because it was one of the few he could afford.
- Golan may allow DNA testing on the bone fragments that had been inside the ossuary after all. "It might be possible to see if someone in the world today is related to James," he told the Globe and Mail. (He earlier told Time he wouldn't allow the bone fragments to be displayed for examination. Instead he'd keep them in a Tupperware container.)
- Golan says he personally supervised the packing of the ossuary "by one of the most reputable shippers of highly valued artifacts in Israel" as it was wrapped "in at least 10 layers" of bubblewrap. He doesn't say why it wasn't packed in a double wooden crate.
Golan also spoke to the Tel Aviv paper Ha'aretz. A few items from that article:
- Golan isn't upset about the ossuary's cracks. "There was some sort of negligence here. I haven't seen it, I want to know what happened. But I believe there is a way to fix it," he says.
- He has insured the ossuary for $1 million, though other reports say it's worth $2 million. Others say it's priceless.
- He has great knowledge of archaeology. (The press conference announcing the ossuary discovery portrayed him as an uninformed hack.)
- Golan says he bought the ossuary "from an authorized dealer," but doesn't remember from whom. "A long time has passed. I was a young boy then," he said. "You don't expect me to remember from whom I bought each of my items."
- The Israeli Antiquities Authority made him sign a document promising to return the ossuary to Israel in February. But the IAA says it "will probably not be declared a national asset, which will enable Golan to sell it to the highest bidder abroad."
- His dog, which has been with him for 20 years, just died. (The dog, says Oded's brother, had musical talent.)
Also, today's Globe and Mail has commentary from television host Lorna Dueck. More importantly, she quotes Paul Maier, professor of ancient history at Western Michigan University. He gives the ossuary an authenticity rating of only six on a 10-point scale. He says the only conclusive evidence would be "finding a crushed skull that may have rested in the ossuary." Still, he says, we don't really need it to know that Jesus really existed. "Evidence outside the Bible in first-century sources for the history of Jesus is overpowering," he says.
- Religious community struggles with war | War tests the normally comfortable fit between duty to God and duty to country, but the prospect that the United States might launch a first strike on Iraq raises even more questions (The Virginian-Pilot, Hampton Roads)
- U.S. Christian leaders rally as peacemakers | Faced with the prospect of war against Iraq, many in mainstream churches view the idea of a preemptive strike as morally at odds with the teachings of the Prince of Peace (St. Petersburg Times)
- Don't call us appeasers for hesitating at war with Iraq | Attacking Saddam is not like resisting Hitler. With nuclear weapons, the whole region is at risk (Rowan Williams, The Daily Telegraph, London)
- Also: Archbishop warns West of nuclear conflict over Iraq (The Daily Telegraph, London)
- Also: Archbishop warns against war (The Guardian, London)
Church and state:
- Housing project illustrates separation of church, state | Officials of the U.S. Housing and Urban Development Department required the church-based organization to build a physical barrier between the 60-unit complex, funded by $4.2 million in federal taxpayer dollars, and the existing Salvation Army church on the adjacent property (Las Vegas Sun)
- Faith in Utah schools | The Beehive State is looked upon by some as a leader in promoting religious liberty in its public classrooms (The Salt Lake Tribune)
- Justices weigh Murray policy on pre-meeting prayers | A free speech debate over what type of prayer is allowed before Murray City Council meetings landed in the Utah Supreme Court on Monday after eight years of legal wrangling (The Salt Lake Tribune)
- Keep church services out of schools: lawyer | A city lawyer warned a federal appeals court yesterday that churches will install themselves permanently in public schools if the judges let a Bronx church hold services at a middle school near Yankee Stadium (New York Post)
- Question of honor roils assembly | First Assembly of God of Orlando must choose between pastor and denomination (The Orlando Sentinel)
- Kentucky's largest church wants to expand campus | Southeast Christian Church is planning a $26.5 million project to add two buildings (Associated Press)
- E-offerings | Passing the collection plate is becoming passé (The Washington Times)
- Fit to be praised | At St. Luke's AME in Harlem, parishioners are learning to treat their bodies like a temple (New York Daily News)
- Vicar fights for clergy's rights | The Reverend Ray Owen says he cannot fight to get his job back because in the UK he is deemed to be "employed by God," and is an office holder rather than employee (BBC)
- Spreading the word in just-the-basics style | James S. Bell Jr, author of four Idiot's Guide books on religion, may be the most prolific condenser of sacred truths on the planet (The New York Times)
- Norman Podhoretz's old-time religion | Norman Podhoretz wraps himself in the apocalyptic rhetoric of the prophets (Judith Shulevitz, The New York Times Book Review)
- Prophets with honor | Norman Podhoretz's illuminating reading of the Bible (Gary A. Anderson, The Weekly Standard)
- Martyrs to Venus | In his lively but uneven book, Richard Godbeer challenges our traditional stereotypes of colonial America by recovering a remarkable volume of sexual discussion and debate, prosecution, and evasion (Alan Taylor, The New Republic)
- Local author's work traces growth of religious right | Cancer kept Ruth Murray Brown from seeing her research on the religious right movement in America published (The Norman [Okla.] Transcript)
- Earning heavenly rewards | Paradise won't be the same for everybody, prominent Christian writer Bruce Wilkinson contends. He says God is 'keeping track,' and a better life here means greater treasure there (The Atlanta Journal-Constitution)
- Book calls Santa, Jesus `rival gods' | In his new book The Sacred Santa: Religious Dimensions of Consumer Culture, former City Councilman Dell deChant suggests Christmas shopping has become as "fully religious" as Christianity itself (The Tampa [Fla.] Tribune)
- Carey 'shunned women priests' | The former Archbishop of Canterbury, Dr George Carey, has been attacked for abandoning women priests in a book marking the tenth anniversary of the vote to ordain them (The Daily Telegraph, London)
Catholic abuse policy revised:
- Mandate to report clergy is altered | Policy on abuse appears undercut (The Boston Globe)
- Catholic leaders defend abuse rule changes | Prelates say Vatican's requests strengthen policy; victims' groups allege backtracking (The Washington Post)
- Policy revisions anger victim advocates (Boston Herald)
- Catholic bishops unveil new policy on accusations of abuse | The revised policy on sexual abuse by the clergy was applauded by canon lawyers and denounced by victims' advocates on Monday (The New York Times)
- Revised abuse policy unveiled by bishop | Accord with Vatican calls for tribunals to hear cases. A statute of limitations is included (Los Angeles Times)
- Priest sex abuse code weakened | Reports to police are not required (Chicago Tribune)
- Bishops walk fine line on abuse policy | Revised plan aims to uphold church law and due process for priests. Critics call for deeper reforms (The Christian Science Monitor)
Sex abuse cases:
- Congregation backs Baptist minister | Congregants rallied around their pastor, the Rev. Lawrence French of First Baptist Church yesterday, saying his tenure should not come to an end despite a ruling that he sexually molested three boys decades ago (The Boston Globe)
- Pell's story tells of great struggle within church | The sectarians of yesteryear must have been spinning in their graves when the Anglican Archbishop of Sydney, Dr Peter Jensen, launched a supportive biography of the Catholic Archbishop of Sydney, Dr George Pell, last week (Paddy McGuinness, The Sydney Morning Herald)
- 3 suits filed against Neb. church | Lawsuits against St. John Lutheran Church in Seward seek millions of dollars for the alleged abuse (Associated Press)
- Former students sue church | Claim to have suffered at the hands of a sexually predatory school official (Lincoln Journal Star)
- Vatican preparing document against gay priests | The document, being worked out by several Vatican departments, is currently in an early drafting stage and it is not clear when it will be released (Reuters)
- Also: Vatican drafts new priesthood rules | The brief statement by the Vatican's Press Office gave no indication what the conclusion may be despite news reports that the document will include directives against the admission of homosexuals (Associated Press)
- Vatican names new envoy to Russia | Seeks to cool tensions with the Russian Orthodox Church (Associated Press)
- Vatican, urging Christians to remain in Holy Land, donates $400,000 | Money to "encourage Christians to remain in these tortured places, like so many missionaries already are doing in heroic fashion" (Associated Press)
- Vatican prefers chastity to condoms | Acknowledged that to some, the Vatican position may sound "ridiculous in the society in which we live." (Associated Press)
Suggest links and stories by sending e-mail to firstname.lastname@example.org
See our past Weblog updates: