The consecration of Norbert Kunonga as the Anglican Bishop of Harare on Sunday, April 29, may have ended months of argument between him and a rival clergyman for the position of bishop.

The argument exposed a wide division in clergy attitudes to the troubled government of President Robert Mugabe.

Norbert Kunonga was consecrated at a ceremony at Harare's City Sports Center. Bishop Kunonga, a 49-year-old black priest and theology lecturer at the Africa University in Mutare, 170 miles east of Harare, succeeds Bishop Jonathan Siyachitema, who retired last October.

Timothy Neill, former vicar general of the diocese, had been fighting since last December to have Kunonga's nomination overturned. Neill, a 47-year-old white priest and prominent critic of the Mugabe government, claimed that the procedure contravened church laws and was "tainted" by racism against whites.

Neill was among three short-listed candidates submitted to the assembly convened in December to elect the new bishop. Kunonga was not on the list. According to the Star newspaper, published in South Africa, Neill's supporters alleged in December that supporters of the Mugabe government blocked Neill's election and engaged in intense lobbying for Kunonga.

Neill said that the clergyman who nominated Kunonga should have been disqualified because he had circulated a letter at the December assembly accusing Neill of racism.

The letter was written by Godfrey Tawonezvi, a priest at St Paul's Church in Highfield, Harare, and sent to Neill. Copies were sent to other priests and deacons. The letter stated: "I note with concern that you are ambitious to be the next Bishop of the Diocese of Harare. My own assessment is that such an ambition by you brings shame to the Church of God."

Tawonezvi accused Neill of racism, of perpetuating racial injustice in the diocese, and of wanting to become bishop in order to continue to dominate blacks. Neill, in turn, claimed that Kunonga had been involved in a smear campaign against him before the selection of the new bishop.

However, on March 9, a 12-member church court of confirmation, comprising two bishops and 10 other clergymen, unanimously confirmed Kunonga's election, brushing aside Neill's objections that he had been slandered.

Neill said last month that Kunonga's nomination was corrupt. "I did not feel that after years of denouncing a corrupt government I could condone similar corruption within the church. The election of Norbert Kunonga included outright slander, deception and lobbying," he said.

Article continues below

Neill did not attend Sunday's ceremony. He said last week that he was leaving for the United States to visit his brother-in-law, who was seriously ill.

Harare's Herald newspaper reported that a number of Anglican priests and parishioners were also conspicuous by their absence.

The consecration took place at a time of deep unrest and confusion in Zimbabwe. Critics both in Zimbabwe and abroad have accused President Robert Mugabe of turning a blind eye to attempts by his supporters to intimidate whites and members of the opposition Movement for Democratic Change.

Bernard Malango, the Zambia-based Archbishop of the Anglican Province of Central Africa, who presided at Kunonga's consecration, gave a homily critical of clergy involvement in politics. Some saw this as an indirect criticism of Neill who is known to his opponents as the "Pulpit Politician."

Archbishop Malango told the congregation of 4,000: "People come to church to hear the word of God and not politics. Those who want to get into politics should do so during their own spare time, and not use the church as a springboard for their ambitions. As members of the church, we are supposed to be speakers of the speechless. This means we have to represent everyone, regardless of their political affiliation."

Neill was removed as vicar general of the diocese in February when the diocese's standing committee passed a vote of no confidence in him.

However, he is still rector of the Anglican parish of St Luke's in Greendale, Harare, despite pressure on him to leave the church. He has led the parish's mainly black congregation of 800 since 1985.

Neill said recently that he had received death threats from people he suspected were government supporters.

Two weeks ago, the state-controlled Herald published a story and an old photograph of Neill wearing a Rhodesian army uniform in an attempt to "expose" him as a "pretender" who claimed to support human rights, but who had been a member of the Rhodesian army which killed thousands of blacks during the liberation struggle in the 1970s.

Neill replied that the photograph showed him at a time when he was completing his compulsory national service with the Rhodesian army.


Related Elsewhere


Local media coverage of the controversy includes:
Kunonga consecrated as Anglican Bishop of HarareThe Herald, Harare (Apr. 30, 2001)

Sordid tale of lies, deceit in Anglican ChurchThe Financial Gazette, Harare (Mar. 15, 2001)

Neill to boycott handoverZimbabwe Standard, Harare (Feb. 3, 2001)

Uncertainty deepens in churchThe Herald (Jan. 23, 2001)

Wrangle over new Anglican bishop ragesThe Herald (Dec. 28, 2000)

Election of Zim bishop was fixed, says NeillThe Star, Johannesburg, South Africa (Dec. 28, 2000)
Article continues below

Christianity Today's earlier coverage of Zimbabwe includes:

Zimbabwe Christians 'Outraged' at Police Role in Student's Death | Catholic Commission for Justice and Peace calls for peace as students demonstrate over low grants. (Apr. 23, 2001)

Conscience, Not Violence, Must Rule Zimbabwe, Says Catholic Priest | Oskar Wermter warns that country is drifting into civil war. (Apr. 12, 2001)

War Veterans Occupy Church on Zimbabwean White-Owned Farm | "We just want to pray and leave politics alone," says evicted pastor. (Apr. 2, 2001)

Priest Horrified as Zimbabwe Politician Compared With 'Son of Man' | Incident is not the first such comparison in Zimbabwe politics. (Apr. 2, 2001)

Evangelicals Attempt to Defuse Crises | While decrying land redistribution program, president of Evangelical Fellowship of Zimbabwe stepping down after financial dispute. (Mar. 22, 2001)

Catholic Clergy Concerned About Workers on Zimbabwe's White Farms | "This is no longer a free country," says Conference of Religious Superiors. (Mar. 22, 2001)

Clergyman Forced to Leave Zimbabwe After Criticizing Mugabe Government | Authorities revoke work permit of Presbyterian missionary who accused the government being involved in killings. (Mar. 19, 2001)

Zimbabwe Church Officials Tell Mugabe to Respect Judiciary and Rule of Law | Catholics, Baptists, and others criticize presidential pressure on Supreme Court. (Mar. 19, 2001)

Churches Call for Inquiry Into Zimbabwe's Pre-Election Violence | "In the meantime, accept the election results" says Zimbabwe Council of Churches (July 14, 2000)

Zimbabwe President's Party Refuses to Join Church-Sponsored Talks to End Violence | At least 10 dead in country's escalating political violence (May 2, 2000)

Evangelicals Abstain from Zimbabwe's Interfaith Body | Christian group opposes blending of Christianity and traditional African religion. (Apr. 18, 2000)

Church Council Urges Swift Resolution of Zimbabwe's Row over White Farms | Land redistribution must be done "in a systematic, just and transparent manner" (Mar. 23, 2000)

Zimbabwe's Black Anglican Priests Claim Exclusion at White Ceremonies | Four priests resign, alleging widespread racism (Nov. 24, 1999)

Gun-Toting Missionaries Given Light Sentences (Nov. 15, 1999)

Missionaries or Mercenaries? (May 24, 1999)