Pastors

The New Worship Topography

After the music wars, the map has changed. How shall we navigate?

Somewhere over the Midwest I asked Ryan in seat 7A what his ideal church would be like. The 26-year-old nominal Catholic with a degree in food science and interest in “spirituality” provided an increasingly common answer: “I don’t understand the rock concert-style churches. I like the practical Bible teaching, but I always find myself wanting to go to Mass instead. Ideally I’d like the liturgy with practical Bible teaching.”

Ryan’s answer hints at the shifts in the worship preferences of many; not just the younger generation’s interest in liturgy, but the general blurring of lines between worship traditions and the theological schools from which they emerged. Today you can find a praise band at St. Mark the Apostle, a Friday night Taize service at First Baptist, and the holy Eucharist adored at Something Creek Community Church.

In this shifting landscape, Exploring the Worship Spectrum proves a valuable roadmap. The contributors intelligently speak to the history, theology, and benefit of six different worship formats, and respond to one another with a level of respect all too rare in most “worship wars.”

Paul Zahl presents the case for formal-liturgical worship that is vertical before it is horizontalโ€” seeking the transcendent holiness of God in a time-tested tradition. The blessing of traditional (hymn-based) worship is presented by Harold Best, the most eloquent, and musically proficient, apologist of the group. Willow Creek’s Joe Horness argues for the contextualized benefit of contemporary worship with humility about its limitations and tempting abuses.

Exploring the Worship Spectrum: 6 Views by Paul Zahl, Harold Best, Joe Horness, Don Williams, Robert Webber, Sally Morgenthaler (Zondervan, 2004) 256 pages; $11.89

Don Williams’s discussion of charismatic worship traces its history from the Jesus Movement to Third Wave. Robert Webber tackles blended worship, redefining it not as choruses and hymns, but as a fourfold structure of gathering, the Word, the table, and sending forth. Finally, Sally Morgenthaler advocates an emerging worship that explores art, culture, and unorthodox forms with the new freedoms afforded the church in a postmodern world.

All six authors are theologically grounded, articulate communicators. At times, however, I found myself frustrated by a discussion that failed to connect. Those from “higher” worship traditions (Zahl, Best, and Webber) and those from “lower” traditions (Horness, Williams, and Morgenthaler) often seem to talk past one another.

The contemporary, emerging, and charismatic worship proponents speak passionately for worship contextualized to a community’s culture. Worship is the heart’s response to God, and we should be free to express that praise in familiar cultural forms that most engage the heart. The liturgical, traditional, and blended worship advocates agree that worship is a response to God, but also see corporate worship as a powerfully formative experience in which God shapes his people. They argue for worship elements that transcend culture and shape us in the stories, symbols, and rich doctrines of the gospel. Because of these different starting points, the book sometimes feels like monologues on worship rather than dialogues between traditions.

This gripe aside, the real benefit of Exploring the Worship Spectrum is not intellectual or cultural arguments, but the overall tone of Christian unity. The work celebrates the diversity of Christ’s church and the rich contribution each worship tradition makes. The book is a wonderful primer on the theology of worship, and ought to be read by every worship leader regardless of tradition. Grounded in biblical theology, with a healthy respect for other perspectives, the book may even assist churches and leaders experiencing tension over worship issues.

This book is a needed resource at a time when, as Harold Best said, “That which should unite our practicesโ€”namely, truthโ€”takes second place to what so often divides usโ€” namely music.”

Skye Jethani, Wheaton, Illinois

Copyright © 2004 by the author or Christianity Today/Leadership Journal.Click here for reprint information onLeadership Journal.

Our Latest

Latino Churchesโ€™ Vibrant Testimony

Hispanic American congregations tend to be young, vibrant, and intergenerational. The wider church has much to learn with and from them.

Review

Modern โ€˜Technocultureโ€™ Makes the World Feel Unnaturally Godless

By changing our experience of reality, it tempts those who donโ€™t perceive God to conclude that he doesnโ€™t exist.

The Bulletin

A Brief Word from Our Sponsor

The Bulletin recaps the 2024 vice presidential debate, discusses global religious persecution, and explores the dynamics of celebrity Christianity.

News

Evangelicals Struggle to Preach Life in the Top Country for Assisted Death

Canadian pastors are lagging behind a national push to expand MAID to those with disabilities and mental health conditions.

Excerpt

The Chinese Christian Who Helped Overcome Illiteracy in Asia

Yan Yangchu taught thousands of peasants to read and write in the early 20th century.

What Would Lecrae Do?

Why Kendrick Lamarโ€™s question matters.

No More Sundays on the Couch

COVID got us used to staying home. But itโ€™s the work of Godโ€™s people to lift up the name of Christ and receive Godโ€™s Wordโ€”together.

Review

Safety Shouldnโ€™t Come First

A theologian questions our habit of elevating this goal above all others.

Apple PodcastsDown ArrowDown ArrowDown Arrowarrow_left_altLeft ArrowLeft ArrowRight ArrowRight ArrowRight Arrowarrow_up_altUp ArrowUp ArrowAvailable at Amazoncaret-downCloseCloseEmailEmailExpandExpandExternalExternalFacebookfacebook-squareGiftGiftGooglegoogleGoogle KeephamburgerInstagraminstagram-squareLinkLinklinkedin-squareListenListenListenChristianity TodayCT Creative Studio Logologo_orgMegaphoneMenuMenupausePinterestPlayPlayPocketPodcastRSSRSSSaveSaveSaveSearchSearchsearchSpotifyStitcherTelegramTable of ContentsTable of Contentstwitter-squareWhatsAppXYouTubeYouTube