News

Responses to ‘Hatchet Job’ Investigation of Evangelical Adoption Movement

(UPDATED) Alternatives to adoption can help combat cultural and communication differences, disputing claims in Kathryn Joyce’s high-profile critique.

Christianity Today April 22, 2013

Update (June 10): The Tennessean explores viable solutions to critiques laid out in Kathryn Joyce’s The Child Catchers. In addition to featuring adoptive families “with heart for missions,” the series of three articles suggest that child sponsorship, foster care, and support of adoptive families can help address differences in communication across cultures, raising orphans’ quality of life and leaving adoption as a last–though potentially successful–option.

––-

Update (June 3): In a front-page story, The New York Times examined the evangelical adoption movement. It notes:

David M. Smolin, director of Samford University’s Center for Children, Law, and Ethics in Alabama and an evangelical, said the new movement has often fallen into the same traps that led a succession of countries, including Guatemala, Cambodia, Vietnam and Nepal, to close down all foreign adoptions after baby-selling scandals.

“Now people are repeating the same mistakes in Uganda and the Democratic Republic of the Congo,” he said.

––-

Update (May 10): CT editor Timothy C. Morgan reviewed Kathryn Joyce’s Child Catchers, saying that Joyce “demonizes overseas adoption through agenda-driven journalism.” Similarly, Her.meneutics author Megan Hill says Joyce’s book focuses on a few cases of adoption with negative consequences, missing out on how adoption benefits women.

––-

Last week, author Kathryn Joyce slammed the “evangelical movement’s adoption obsession,” critiquing what she calls an “epic mismatch of children’s needs and parents’ propensities.”

But defenders of the evangelical adoption movement are speaking out against Joyce’s claims, just in time for the release this week of her new book, The Child Catchers: Rescue, Trafficking, and the New Gospel of Adoption.

Religion News Service columnist Jonathan Merritt says Joyce paints a “partial and distorted picture,” making her argument by leaning on “a slew of fringe ministries, publications, and personalities.”

Merritt writes:

Joyce curses the darkness without lighting a candle. She attempts to pour cold water on the Christian adoption movement, but her ideas for actually solving the orphan crisis that now affects more than 100 million children are more than lacking; they’re non-existent. We should expect more from even an unashamedly partisan publication like Mother Jones. Not to mention a writer who recently published a 352-page book on the subject.

Similarly, LifeWay Research president Ed Stetzer says the book is “more of a hit-and-run journalistic hatchet job on evangelical adoption than a substantive investigation of any kind.” On his blog, Stetzer offers his own Q&A roundup with evangelical adoption experts, including Bethany Christian Services’s Johnny Carr, Jedd Medefind of the Christian Alliance for Orphans, Rebecca Caswell of Lemonade International, and Orphanology coauthors Tony Merida and Rick Morton.

CT regularly reports on the issue of adoption. Recently, CT highlighted the rise of open adoptions, and looked at how adoption became new ERLC president-elect Russell Moore’s personal cause.

Our Latest

News

Charlie Kirk Aims to Expand Turning Point USA to Evangelical Campuses

But not all Christian campuses have embraced the conservative group.

News

Sarah Jakes Roberts Evolves T. D. Jakes’s Women’s Conference

At a record-setting event this fall, 40,000 followers listened to her preach about spiritual breakthrough and surrender.

Being Human

Walking the Camino de Santiago with Barrett Harkins

The missionary to pilgrims shares wisdom from the trail.

News

The Evangelical Voters Who Changed Their Minds

Amid a hyperpartisan electorate, a minority plan to vote differently than they did in 2016 and 2020.

News

Meet the Evangelical Expats Staying in Lebanon

Shout to the Lord in a Foreign Language

Worshiping God with words we don’t understand may seem strange. But I consider it a spiritual practice.

Jesus Is Still Right About Persecution

Nine truths believers need to understand to pray well for the suffering body of Christ.

The Bulletin

Electioneering

The Bulletin discusses the final presidential campaign push, churches in the age of screens, and the UN’s work in Gaza.

Apple PodcastsDown ArrowDown ArrowDown Arrowarrow_left_altLeft ArrowLeft ArrowRight ArrowRight ArrowRight Arrowarrow_up_altUp ArrowUp ArrowAvailable at Amazoncaret-downCloseCloseEmailEmailExpandExpandExternalExternalFacebookfacebook-squareGiftGiftGooglegoogleGoogle KeephamburgerInstagraminstagram-squareLinkLinklinkedin-squareListenListenListenChristianity TodayCT Creative Studio Logologo_orgMegaphoneMenuMenupausePinterestPlayPlayPocketPodcastRSSRSSSaveSaveSaveSearchSearchsearchSpotifyStitcherTelegramTable of ContentsTable of Contentstwitter-squareWhatsAppXYouTubeYouTube